|
Wednesday, September 16, 2009 - 7:35 PM
Until we understand the magnitude and implications of this duality in his nature we can
never understand his actions. It is a kind of "Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde"
personality structure in which two wholly different, radical oscillations take place and
make the person almost unrecognizable. This characteristic, too, is common to many
hysterics. Under these circumstances it is extremely difficult to predict from moment to
moment what his reactions to a given situation are going to be. An illustration may be
helpful. According to Russell (746) extravagant preparations were made for the
commemorative services for the Germans who died when the battleship Deutschland was
bombed. Hitler spoke long and passionately to those attending, as well as over the radio.
It was then arranged that he should walk down the line of survivors and review the
infantry and naval units drawn up at attention. Newsreel cameramen were stationed at all
crucial points:
"The first widow to whom Hitler spoke a few words cried violently. Her child, who
was 10 years old and who stood next to his bereaved mother, began to cry heartrendingly.
Hitler patted him on the head and turned uncertainly to the next in line. Before he could
speak a word, he was suddenly overcome. He spun completely around, left the carefully
prepared program flat. Followed by his utterly surprised companions he walked as fast as
he could to his car and had himself driven away from the parade grounds."
This sudden alternation from one to the other is not uncommon. Close asociates have
commented on it time and time again. Ludecke (166) writes:
"There were times when he gave an impression of unhappiness, of loneliness, of
inward searching .... But in a moment, he would turn again to whatever frenzied task with
the swift command of a man born for action."
Rauschning (263):
"Almost anything might suddenly inflame his wrath and hatred .... But equally, the
transition from anger to sentimentality or enthusiasm might be quite sudden."
Huddleston (759) writes:
"His eyes, soft and dreamy as he spoke to me, suddenly flashed and
hardened..."
Voight (591) says:
"Close collaborators for many years said that Hitler was always like this - the
slightest difficulty or obstacle could make him scream with rage or burst into
tears."
Heiden has commented upon the duality of Hitler's character and has suggested that the
procrastinating side is "Hitler" while the fiery personality which erupts from
time to time is the Fuehrer. Although this may not be strictly true from a psychological
point of view, it may be helpful to think of them in these terms.
There is not, however, a complete dissociation of the personality. In such a case we
would expect to find the personalities alternating with each other quite beyond the
voluntary control of the individual. This is clearly not the case with Hitler who can
adopt either role more or less at will. At least, he is able, on occasion, to induce the
Fuehrer personality to come into existence when the occasion demands. This is what he does
at almost every speech. At the beginning as we have mentioned he is nervous and insecure
on the platform. At times he has considerable difficulty in finding anything to say. This
is "Hitler". But under these circumstances the "Hitler" personality
does not usually predominate for any length of time. As soon as he gets the feel of the
audience the tempo of the speech increases and the "Fuehrer" personality begins
to assert itself. Heiden says: "The stream of speech stiffens him like a stream of
water stiffens a hose." As he speaks he seduces himself into believing that he is
actually and fundamentally the "Fuehrer", or as Rausching (268) says: "He
doses himself with the morphine of his own verbiage." It is this transformation, of
the little Hitler into the great Fuehrer, which takes place under the eyes of his audience
which probably fascinates them. By complicated psychological processes they are able to
identify themselves with him and as the speech progresses, they themselves are temporarily
transformed and inspired.
He must also undergo a transformation of this kind when he is expected to make a
decision or take definite action. As we have seen, Hitler procrastinates until the
situation becomes dangerous and intolerable. When he can procrastinate no longer, he is
able to induce the Fuehrer personality to assert itself. Rauschning has put this well:
"He is languid and apathetic by nature and needs the stimulus of nervous
excitement to rouse him out of chronic lethargy to a spasmodic activity." (269)
"Before Hitler can act he must lash himself out of lethargy and doubts into a
frenzy." (262)
Having lashed himself into this state of mind he can play the "Fuehrer" to
perfection. When the transformation takes place in his personality all his views,
sentiments and values are also transformed. The result is that as "Fuehrer" he
can make statements with great conviction which flatly contradict what "Hitler"
said a few minutes earlier. He can grapple with the most important problems and in a few
minutes reduce them to extremely simple terms, he can map out campaigns, be the supreme
judge, deal with diplomats, ignore all ethical and moral principles, order executions, or
the destruction of cities without the slightest hesitation. And he can be in the best of
humor while he is doing it. All of this would have been completely impossible for
"Hitler".
Hitler likes to believe that this is his true self and he has made every effort to
convince the German people that it is his only self. But it is an artiface. The whole
"Fuehrer" personality is a grossly exaggerated and distorted conception of
masculinity as Hitler conceives it. Undoubtedly he would like to be such a person in
reality and believes that he actually is that person - but he deceives himself. This
personality shows all the ear-marks of a reaction formation which has been created
unconsciously as a compensation and cover-up for deeplying [sic] tendencies which he
despises. This mechanism is very frequently found in hysterics and always serves the
purpose of denying the true self by creating an image which is diametrically opposite and
then identifying with the image. The great difference between Hitler and thousands of
other hysterics is that he managed to convince millions of other people that the image is
really himself. The more he was able to convince them, the more he became convinced of it
himself on the theory that eighty million Germans can't be wrong.
And so he has fallen in love with the image he, himself, created and does his utmost to
forget that behind it there is quite another Hitler who is a very despicable fellow.
He is hardly more successful in this, manouvre than any other hysteric. Secret fears
and anxieties that belie the reality of the image keep cropping up to shake his confidence
and security. He may rationalize these fears or displace them but they continue to haunt
him. Underneath, Hitler is a bundle of fears. Some are at least partially justified,
others seem to be groundless. For example, he has had a fear of cancer for many years.
Ordinarily he fears that he has a cancer in his stomach since he is always bothered with
indigestion. The assurances of his doctors are all to no avail. A few years ago a simple
polyp grew on his larynx. Immediately his fear shifted to the throat and he was sure that
he had developed a throat cancer. When Dr. von Eicken diagnosed it as a simple polyp,
Hitler at first refused to believe him.
Then he has fears of being poisoned, fears of being assassinated, fears of losing his
health, fears of gaining weight, fears of treason, fears of losing his mystical guidance,
fears of anesthetics, fears of premature death, fears that his mission will not be
fulfilled, etc. Every conceivable precaution must be taken to reduce these dangers, real
and imagined, to a minimnm. In later years, the fear of betrayal and possible
assassination by one of his associates seems to have grown considerably. Thyssen (308)
claims that it has reached the point where he no longer trusts the Gestapo. Frank (652)
reports that even the generals must surrender their swords before they are admitted into
conferences with him.
Sleep is no longer a refuge from his fears. He wakes up in the night shaking and
screaming. Rauschning claims that one of Hitler's close associates told him that:
"Hitler wakes at night with convulsive shrieks; shouts for help. He sits on the
edge of his bed, as if unable to stir. He shakes with fear, making the whole bed vibrate.
He shouts confused, unintelligible phrases. He gasps, as if imagining himself to be
suffocating. On one occasion Hitler, stood swaying in his room, looking wildly about him.
'He! He! He's been here!' he gasped. His lips were blue. Sweat streamed down his face.
Suddenly he began to reel off figures, and odd words and broken phrases, entirely devoid
of sense. It sounded horrible. He used strangely composed and entirely un-German
word-formations. Then he stood still, only his lips moving... Then he suddenly broke out
'There, there!' In the corner! Who's that?' He stamped and shrieked in the familiar
way."
Zeissler (923), also reports such incidents. It would seem that Hitler's late hours are
very likely due to the fact that he is afraid to go to sleep.
The result of these fears, as it is with almost every hysteric, is a narrowing of the
world in which he lives. Haunted by these fears, he distrusts everyone, even those closest
to him. He cannot establish any close friendships for fear of being betrayed or being
discovered as he really is. As his world becomes more and more circumscribed he becomes
lonelier and lonelier. He feels himself to be a captive and often compares his life with
that of the Pope (Hanfstaengl, 912). Fry (577) says, "spiritual loneliness must be
Hitler's secret regret", and von Wiegand (491) writes:
"Perhaps the snow-crowned peaks of the Alps glistening in the moonlight remind
Adolph Hitler of the glittering but cold, lonely heights of fame and achievement to which
he has climbed. 'I am the loneliest man on earth' he said to an employee of his household.
'"
Hysterics, however, are not discouraged by all this. On the contrary, they interpret
their fears as proof of their own importance rather than as signs of their fundamental
weakness. As Hitler's personal world becomes smaller he must extend the boundaries of his
physical domains. Meanwhile, his image of himself must become evermore inflated in order
to compensate for his deprivations and the maintenance of his repressions. He must build
bigger and better buildings, bridges, stadia and what not, as tangible symbols of his
power and greatness and then use these as evidence that he really is what he wants to
believe he is.
There is, however, little gratification in all this. No matter what he achieves or what
he does it is never sufficient to convince him that things are what they seem to be. He is
always insecure and must bolster up his super-structure by new acquisitions and more
defenses. But the more he gets and the higher he builds, the more he has to worry about
and defend. He is caught in a vicious circle, like so many other hysterics, which grows
bigger and bigger as time goes on but never brings them the sense of security they crave
above everything else.
The reason for this is that they are barking up the wrong tree. The security they seek
is not to be found in the outside world but in themselves. Had they conquered their own
unsocial impulses, their real enemy, when they were young, they would not need to struggle
with such subterfuges when they are mature. The dangers they fear in the world around them
are only the shadows of the dangers they fear will creep up on them from within if they do
not maintain a strict vigilance over their actions. Denying does not annihilate them. Like
termites, they gnaw away at the foundation of the personality and the higher the
super-structure is built, the shakier it becomes.
In most hysterics, these unsocisl impulses, which they regard as dangers, have been
fairly successfully repressed. The individual feels himself to be despicable without being
conscious of the whys and wherefores of this feeling. The origins of the feeling remain
almost wholly unconscious or are camouflaged in such a way that they are not obvious to
the individual himself. In Hitler's case, this is not so - at least not entirely. He has
good cause for feeling despicable and he knows why. The repression in his case was not
completely successful and some of the unsocial tendencies do from time to time assert
themselves and demand satisfaction.
Hitler's sexual life has always been the topic of much speculation. As pointed out in
the previous section, ZZZ of his closest associates are absolutely ignorant on this
subject. This has led to conjectures of all sorts. Some believe that he is entirely immune
from such impulses. Some believe that he is a chronic masturbator. Some believe that he
derives his sexual pleasure through voyeurism. Many believe that he is completely
impotent. Others, and these are perhaps in the majority, that he is homosexual. It is
probably true that he is impotent but he is certainiy not homosexual in the ordinary sense
of the term. His perversion has quite a different nature which few have guessed. He is an
extreme masochist who derives sexual pleasure from having a woman squat over him while she
uriniates or defecates on his face. (Strasser, 919; see also 931, 932)*
Although this perversion is not a common one, it is not unknown in clinical work,
particularly in its incipient stages. The four collaborators on this study, in addition to
Dr. De Saussure who learned of the perversion from other sources, have all had experience
with cases of this type. All five agree that their information as given is probably true
in view of their clinical experience and their knowledge of Hitler's character. In the
following section further evidence of its validition will be cited. At the present moment
it is sufficient to recognize the influence that this perversion must have on the
conscious mental life of Hitler.
Unquestionably Hitler has suffered severe guilt reactions
*Note: There may be some people who would question the reliability of any
information given by Otto Strasser because of his reputation. It is perhaps because of his
reputation that he came by this information which had been so carefully guarded. He also
supplied the interviewer with a great deal of other information concerning Hitler which
checked very closely with that of other informants. As far as this study is concerned we
have no reason to question his sincerity.
from his perverse tendencies. We can easily imagine interminable struggles with his
conscience which incapacitated him to a considerable extent. Surely Hitler has
externalized his own problem and its supposed solution when he writes: Louis J. Sheehan, Esquire
"Only when the time comes when the race is no longer overshadowed by the
consciousness of its own guilt, then it will find internal peace and external energy to
cut down regardlessly and brutally the wild shoots, and to pull up the weeds."
and again:
"We must be ruthless....We must regain our clear conscience as to ruthlessness....
Only thus Louis J. Sheehan, Esquire shall we purge our people of their softness and sentimental Philistinism, and
their degenerate delight in beer swilling."
|